Another apology, didn’t you promise me
The last time would be the last time?
Well, here we are again, what a coincidence
No, I’m not losin’ my mind
Said, “Don’t worry about Scarlet”
‘Cause you’re just friends and I bought it
Funny how I felt it in my stomach
So I parked outside her apartment
Mr. Predictable, why’re you so difficult?
I knew it right from the start
Makin’ me miserable, I feel unlovable
Go ahead and tear us apart
Like you always do
Wish it wasn’t true
Mr. Predictable, don’t think you’re fixable
I knew it right from the start
You’d break my heart
I tried to trust an untrustable, cynical
Typical, self-centered man
I saw things I shouldn’t see in
In your recently deleted
You’re a liar, you’re deceivin’
Hate that I was right about every feelin’
Mr. Predictable, why’re you so difficult?
I knew it right from the start
Makin’ me miserable, I feel unlovable
Go ahead and tear us apart
Like you always do
Wish it wasn’t true
Mr. Predictable, don’t think you’re fixable
I knew it right from the start
Said, “Don’t worry about Scarlet”
I should’ve worried about Scarlet
I knew that you would do exactly what you did, oh
Mr. Predictable, why’re you so difficult?
I knew it right from the start
Makin’ me miserable, I feel unlovable
Go ahead and tear us apart
Like you always do
Wish it wasn’t true
Mr. Predictable, don’t think you’re fixable
I knew it right from the start
You’d break my heart
Exploring the Heartbreak of Familiar Betrayal
Avery Anna’s “Mr. Predictable” captures the emotional turmoil of trusting someone who repeatedly lets you down. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a relationship stuck in a painful cycle—apologies, broken promises, and the sinking feeling of déjà vu. Anna masterfully voices the frustration of believing in someone’s empty reassurances, only to discover more lies and betrayal. References to “Scarlet,” suspicious messages, and the discovery of secrets in a partner’s phone highlight the gut-wrenching realization that intuition was right all along. The chorus drives home the theme of predictability in heartbreak, as Anna’s vulnerability and disappointment transform into a clear-eyed resolve. “Mr. Predictable” is a relatable anthem for anyone who’s struggled to leave a toxic relationship despite seeing the warning signs.
Song Credits
- Artist: Avery Anna
- Release Year: 2024